The Truth About Conscience

Friday of Week 22 in Ordinary Time (Year II)
1 Corinthians 4:1-5 | Psalm 36:3-6,27-28,39-40 | Luke 5:33-39


True, my conscience does not reproach me at all, but that does not prove that I am acquitted: the Lord alone is my judge. (1 Corinthians 4:4)

During my catechism classes as a child, I’d been drilled on the importance of conscience, that little voice inside me that tells right from wrong. I’d been taught to always follow that conscience, no matter how difficult it proves to be.

However, I was never told how my conscience worked, so it was fortuitous that I stumbled across this article about conscience by Deacon Douglas McManaman. It made me realize that my conscience was actually my humanly-incomplete interpretation of Divine Law, and therefore it can be wrong.

So it should not come as a surprise when I confess to one and all that my conscience had been ill-informed for a very long time. In particular, I’d spent my time daydreaming at catechism, instead of taking in the knowledge of faith that Fr. Louis Foisson was patiently (thought sometimes a little grumpily) imparting to us, so the conscience of my younger self was a rather weak and uncertain voice.

That “justifiable” sin I mentioned yesterday about pilfering office supplies for personal use? I did that 20 years ago, and I never gave it a second thought at the time. Indeed, I might have gone on to bigger larcenies, had my natural timidity not held me back from exploring the darker depths of human activity.

I think my conscience is better-informed and quite a bit louder now, thanks to my oldest friend regularly questioning my Catholic knowledge, and my new habit of nightly scriptural reflections. It’s still far from perfect, of course, so St. Paul’s honest self-appraisal serves as a timely deflation of ego.

All I can do now is to “feed” it regularly with the Church’s teachings, be unafraid to let it lead me wherever I must go and do whatever I should do in Christ’s name, and to trust in the mercy of Almighty God when my mortal existence comes to an end.

Amen.

Unknown Knowns

Thursday of Week 22 in Ordinary Time (Year II)
1 Corinthians 3:18-23 | Psalm 23:1-6 | Luke 5:1-11


Make no mistake about it: if any one of you thinks of himself as wise, in the ordinary sense of the word, then he must learn to be a fool before he really can be wise. (1 Corinthians 3:18)

 

In my work as a freelance consultant, I usually have to start by asking questions about my clients’ operating environment, issues, expectations, etc. I often have to fight a tendency to correlate my own IT experience with theirs, as that usually ends with me making unwarranted assumptions about what’s happening in their world.

But it also means that I can look incompetent to the client, by asking questions that are deemed “stupid”. Upon further digging, though, it often turns out that they don’t actually know the answers either, which can be an embarrassing realisation when their own subordinates go “well, actually, we don’t have any such thing in place” or “um, that’s not how it works”.

Former U.S. Defence Secretary Donald Rumsfeld answered media queries about Iraq’s supposed weapons of mass destruction with his now-infamous “there are known knowns” response. Using his known/unknown matrix, my clients’ known knowns really aren’t. A major part of my day job is convincing them to reclassify these things as known unknowns that require further investigation, before proposing solutions to their problems.

Sometimes, though, that takes major effort. After all, everyone loves to claim that they’re humble, but no one likes to look like he just fooled himself.

✞ ✞ ✞ ✞ ✞

Rumsfeld avoided talking about a particular quadrant in that matrix: the unknown knowns, the things we know, but convince ourselves that we don’t. Mostly inconvenient things like torture, atrocities and miscellaneous war crimes.

And “justifiable” sins, the ones we think don’t hurt anyone to any significant degree, and are therefore “inconsequential to God” – but we still don’t like to dwell on them:

  • The extra office supplies we took home for personal use, because “they already budgeted for it, so they don’t lose anything”.
  • The many times we enjoyed free rides on buses by “unconsciously” keeping our travel cards in our pockets, because we were too preoccupied with other things, and anyway “LTA keeps raising bus fares, cannot afford lah!”
  • The queues for free stuff that we jump by “filling in that gap someone left in the middle”, otherwise “sure run out one!”
  • The loading bays we park in because “yah what, I’m loading my stomach mah!”

Part of my daily reflection centers around opening the “inner eye” to the things I did earlier in the day, and whether I’m OK with them. In the process, I often have to struggle with my own pride, answering an initial “I think I handled that situation quite well” with “nope, you took way too much pleasure proving him wrong, even if you didn’t show it…much”.

Unknown knowns may be painful to recollect, but we can’t grow as Christians without acknowledging all our sins, even the secret ones in which we think no one got hurt or even knew. One person is always hurt, one person always knows: the One who suffered and died to redeem us from all our transgressions, only to watch us walk away from Him all over again.

Open my eyes, Lord, to the many ways that I hurt you each day. Show me the depth of Your pain, and help me to turn away from sin and towards You, for You are deserving of all our love and praise. Amen.

Rebuke Us, O Lord

Wednesday of Week 22 in Ordinary Time (Year II)
1 Corinthians 3:1-9 | Psalm 32:12-15,20-21 | Luke 4:38-44


Leaning over her he rebuked the fever and it left her. (Luke 4:39)

Picture a child inspired by this passage to stand over her ill mother and loudly declaim: “BAD FEVER, BAD! GO AWAY!” I’d imagine the poor parent would be torn between a wry smile at such tender innocence…and a heartfelt plea: “Hush now, sweetie, not so loud. Mommy’s got a terrible headache!”

But just a few sentences later in today’s Gospel we read this:

Devils too came out of many people, howling, ‘You are the Son of God.’ But he rebuked them and would not allow them to speak because they knew that he was the Christ. (Luke 4:41)

I thought Luke’s multiple uses of “rebuke” to be rather odd, until I discovered that the word is used six different ways in translated scripture, according to the King James Dictionary. Today’s Gospel passage is therefore better understood as:

Leaning over her he [stopped] the fever and it left her.

and:

Devils too came out of many people, howling, ‘You are the Son of God.’ But he [silenced] them and would not allow them to speak because they knew that he was the Christ.

So much meaning packed in a single word.

Lord God Almighty, we implore you:
rebuke (chide) us when we stray,
rebuke (restrain) Satan from turning us away from You,
rebuke (punish) us not in Your anger,
rebuke (silence) us when we spread falsehoods,
rebuke (heal) our physical and spiritual maladies,
rebuke (calm) our stormy passions and restless hearts,
so that we may be reunited with You at the end of days,
to sing your praises for ever. Amen.

The Evangelist’s Dilemma

Tuesday of Week 22 in Ordinary Time (Year II)
1 Corinthians 2:10-16 | Psalm 144:8-14 | Luke 4:31-37


Therefore we teach, not in the way in which philosophy is taught, but in the way that the Spirit teaches us: we teach spiritual things spiritually. (1 Corinthians 2:13)

There’s a classic philosophical conundrum called the Prisoner’s Dilemma, in which two guilty suspects can actually escape punishment by not telling on each other, but are nevertheless biased towards betrayal to avoid being the prison-bound sucker. Completely rational people therefore choose to “rat out the other guy” and smugly pat themselves on the back.

A gang member then says, “But if my bro stays silent and I go free, my gang will know that I betrayed him, and then I’m a dead man!” The completely rational people pause in confusion.

A Catholic then says, “Why so complicated? You don’t want to do the time, don’t do the crime!”

The completely rational people stone the Catholic to death. Everyone secretly wants to “get away with it”, so nobody likes a Spirit-filled smartass.

Trying to explain our faith in secular terms is difficult, because mundane existence largely revolves around the animal instinct of distrust: I don’t know you, therefore I have to assume that you won’t act in my interests, so I’d better get the first stab in before the fileting frenzy begins. Fake smiles and personal gain come to the fore.

But the Spirit impels us to look “through the eyes of love”: I don’t know you, but we are all God’s children, so there’s no cause for stabbing. Here, I hope this kindness benefits you. Acts of mercy and a general aura of care for others are the “catch of the day”.

As flawed beings striving to be more loving each day, we naturally have one foot in each camp, but I think this can actually help attract others to the cause of Christ: Look, you see me as I am. I’m not “holier than thou,” just a guy trying to be a better person each day and, in my own small way, trying to make this corner of the world a better place for everyone. By myself, I’d have a snowball’s chance in hell of even getting started, but I’m getting help from a great man. His name is Jesus Christ. Would you like to get to know him too?

Amen.

The Power of the Truth

The Passion of Saint John the Baptist
Jeremiah 1:17-19 | Psalm 70:1-6,15,17 | Mark 6:17-29


St. John the Baptist publicly declaimed a bigamous queen…and had his head cut off in today’s Gospel.

An eye surgeon at the National Eye Centre crudely described a laser procedure as “drilling two holes in your eyes”, which frightened my wife’s friend so much that she elected to have a private doctor work on her instead, one who cost quite a bit more but had substantially better EQ (emotional quotient).

A decorated Olympic swimmer lied about an embarrassing incident in a foreign country, and became the shame of his nation when details on what really happened finally emerged. (As of this writing, he still steadfastly refuses to make a proper apology.)

✞ ✞ ✞ ✞ ✞

It’s clear that words have power, and words of Truth doubly so. Herod knew that he had sinned in marrying his brother’s wife, yet he recognized and respected the Truth that St. John the Baptist proclaimed, and protected him from Herodias’ wrath until a careless promise (those pesky words again) forced his executioner’s hand. Similarly, God assured the prophet Jeremiah in today’s reading that he would be safeguarded against all harm from earthly authority, as long as he faithfully proclaimed His Truth.

Sadly, we generally have to phrase the Truth a bit more delicately in modern times. For instance, the Church’s stand on abortion can be a particularly sore point even in casual discussion, and trying to engage the “my body, my rules” crowd often ends with much heat and a deeply-divided room.

It’s also possible to be wrong when sharing God’s Word. I keep reminding myself of this each night when I add to this blog, and I keep hoping that someone will eventually sound off with “you’re wrong, scripture / CCC / tradition actually says ABC about XYZ”. Few things would give me more pleasure than a Truth-based mea culpa; I don’t get to say “I got schooled” enough these days.

✞ ✞ ✞ ✞ ✞

I’ve had many ecclesial discussions with my old atheist buddy over the years. While I can never quite remember what was said on either side (though I’m quite sure we haven’t touched on abortions yet), I’m thankful that it keeps me jogging along on the Way of Truth. His incisive ripostes also force me to stop, reconsider my long-held “truths” that might not be so, and choose my words with great care, as we all should when imparting the Truth to others.

It also helps that he seems to be taking our discussions seriously, so I may yet persuade him to cross over to the “light side”. Finally, neither of us cross the line into pro-/anti-Christian polemics, which I think is most important in evangelisation.

After all, regardless of which side of the religious divide we happen to inhabit, it doesn’t pay to lose our heads over it.